2019 Softball All-Conference Team
2019 SLIAC Player of the Year: Sydney Shubert, Eureka College
2019 SLIAC Pitcher of the Year: Morgan Christner, Iowa Wesleyan University
2019 SLIAC Newcomer of the Year: Raelyn Payne, Eureka College
2019 SLIAC Coach of the Year: Debi Neff, Eureka College
2019 SLIAC Team Sportsmanship Award: Principia College
| SLIAC | First Team | |
| Pos. | Player | School |
| P | Morgan Christner | Iowa Wesleyan |
| P | Erin Smith | Eureka |
| C | Lauren Daugherty | Principia |
| INF | Hannah Hathaway | Principia |
| INF | Ally Klein | Spalding |
| INF | Morgan Ledbetter | Eureka |
| INF | Kayla Zimmerman | Greenville |
| OF | Kayla Ford | Iowa Wesleyan |
| OF | Beth Mersinger | Greenville |
| OF | Sydney Shubert | Eureka |
| UT | Madison Washington | Westminster |
| AL (C) | Mac Henderson | Spalding |
| SLIAC | Second Team | |
| P | Olivia Carter | Spalding |
| P | Maegan Stone | Greenville |
| C | Morgan Osborn | Eureka |
| INF | Megan Barrett | Greenville |
| INF | Meka Elmore | MacMurray |
| INF | Mikala Guthrie | Westminster |
| INF | Raelyn Payne | Eureka |
| OF | Abby Burroughs | Webster |
| OF | Lauren Huskey | Westminster |
| OF | Mackenzie Myers | Westminster |
| UT | Diamond Thomas | Fontbonne |
| AL (INF) | Kendall Farr | Greenville |
| SLIAC | Third Team | |
| P | Tessa Beckham | Blackburn |
| P | Madison Ingram | Westminster |
| C | Hannah Schroeder | Westminster |
| INF | Alex Eyman | Iowa Wesleyan |
| INF | Baylee Hughes | Blackburn |
| INF | Taylor White | Westminster |
| INF | Adrianna Zeman | Eureka |
| OF | Delaney Gatine | Principia |
| OF | Addie Morris | Spalding |
| OF | Jennifer Peffley | Spalding |
| UT | Deidra Holzhauer | Greenville |
| AL (INF) | Sheyla Iniguez | Webster |
| SLIAC | All-Sportsmanship Team | |
| Lexie Yockey | Blackburn | |
| Faith Bachtold | Eureka | |
| Abby Richmond | Fontbonne | |
| Cayla Speaks | Greenville | |
| Lara Needham | Iowa Wesleyan | |
| Brooke Allen | MacMurray | |
| Hannah Hathaway | Principia | |
| Bri Eatmon | Spalding | |
| Abby Burroughs | Webster | |
| Abbey Jaspering | Westminster |