Justin Peery lettered two years in men's basketball but made his mark at Westminster as a four-year letter winner in football. He was a four-time All-SLIAC recipient at quarterback from 1996-99 and was named SLIAC Football Player of the Year in 1998 and SLIAC Football Offensive MVP in 1999. In addition to his conference accolades, Peery also earned Football Gazette, Hewlett Packard and USA Football III All-America honors in 1998 and 1999, and he was an AP Little All-American in 1999. In four years, Peery threw for a NCAA Division III career record 13,262 yards and a NCAA all divisions record 148 touchdowns. Peery graduated from Westminster in 2000 with a degree in education.