2017 SLIAC Player of the Year: Erica Burney, Westminster College
2017 SLIAC Pitcher of the Year: Alyson Hahn, Westminster College
2017 SLIAC Newcomer of the Year: Josie Cotter, Westminster College
2017 SLIAC Coach of the Year: Joe Henderson, Westminster College
2017 SLIAC Team Sportsmanship Award: Eureka College
| SLIAC | First Team | ||
| Pos. | Player | School | Yr. |
| P | Brianna Anderson |
Greenville | Sr. |
| P | Alyson Hahn |
Westminster | Sr. |
| C | Emelia Modglin |
Fontbonne | So. |
| INF | Erica Burney |
Westminster | Sr. |
| INF | Kerrigan Dura |
Eureka | So. |
| INF |
Kate Jolliff |
Greenville | Jr. |
| INF | Tiffany Samsoe |
Greenville | Sr. |
| OF | Daniele Burnell |
Blackburn |
Jr. |
| OF | Amber Tepen |
Westminster | Jr. |
| OF | Krysten Wallace |
Eureka | Jr. |
| UT | Kali George |
Eureka | Jr. |
| AL | Courtney Kedroski (INF) |
Fontbonne |
Jr. |
| SLIAC | Second Team | ||
| P | Katie Price |
Westminster |
Fr. |
| P | Robyn Schoen |
Spalding | Jr. |
| C | Aubrie Vaughn |
Westminster |
Fr. |
| INF | Anne Baker |
Westminster | Sr. |
| INF | Abby Burroughs |
Webster | Fr. |
| INF | Lindsey Hubbard |
Spalding | So. |
| NF | Becca Oldham |
Greenville | Jr. |
| OF | Maddie Cooksey |
Fontbonne |
So. |
| OF | Josie Koontz |
Greenville |
Jr. |
| OF | Katelyn Sullens |
Webster | Sr. |
| UT | Hannah Goett |
Blackburn | Jr. |
| AL | Josie Cotter (UT) |
Westminster | Fr. |
| SLIAC | Third Team |
||
| P | Morgan Mansur |
Webster |
Jr. |
| P |
Samantha McIlwain | Iowa Wesleyan |
Jr. |
| C |
Caitlin O'Neill |
Iowa Wesleyan |
Sr. |
| INF |
Kayla Day |
Webster | Sr. |
| INF |
Hannah Hathaway |
Principia | Fr. |
| INF |
Katelyn Johnson |
Webster | Sr. |
| INF |
Sam Klein |
Spalding | Jr. |
| OF |
Shelby Cash |
Greenville |
Sr. |
| OF |
Callie Collier |
Westminster | Fr. |
| OF | Mackenzie Myers |
Westminster | Fr. |
| UT |
Diamond Thomas |
Fontbonne | So. |
| AL |
Mackenzie Henderson |
Spalding |
Fr. |
| AL | Kassie Vasquez | Iowa Wesleyan | Sr. |
| SLIAC | All-Sportsmanship Team | ||
| Hannah Goett | Blackburn | ||
| Courtney Kurtz |
Eureka | ||
| Kayla Winkler |
Fontbonne | ||
| Cassandra Lueking |
Greenville | ||
| Kassie Vasquez |
Iowa Wesleyan | ||
| Jessica Stanton |
MacMurray | ||
| AC McMullen |
Principia | ||
| Brianna Eatmon |
Spalding | ||
| Sidney Coleman |
Webster | ||
| Lexi Knisley |
Westminster |