2023 Softball All-Conference Team
2023 SLIAC Player of the Year: Mia Boyd, Greenville University
2023 SLIAC Pitcher of the Year: Alison Klaus, Greenville University
2023 SLIAC Newcomer of the Year: Michaela Ferman, Spalding University
2023 SLIAC Coach of the Year: Art Williams, Spalding University
2023 SLIAC Team Sportsmanship Award: Blackburn College
| SLIAC | First Team | |||||
| Pos. | Player | School | Yr | Hometown/High School | ||
| P | Michaela Ferman | Spalding | FR | Metamora, Ind./Franklin County | ||
| P | Alison Klaus | Greenville | SR | O'Fallon, Mo./Fort Zumwalt West | ||
| C | Grace Paez | Fontbonne | JR | St. Louis, Mo./Incarnate Word | ||
| INF | Mia Boyd | Greenville | SO | Florissant, Mo./Incarnate Word | ||
| INF | Katie Croxall | Webster | SO | El Segundo, Calif./El Segundo | ||
| INF | Lilly Jones | Fontbonne | SR | Benton, Mo./Thomas W. Kelly | ||
| INF | Bella Velez | Spalding | JR | Louisville, Ky./Holy Cross | ||
| OF | Emily Esquivel | Westminster | JR | San Diego, Calif./Eastlake | ||
| OF | Grayce Marcum | Spalding | SO | Indianapolis, Ind./Franklin Central | ||
| OF | Jessica Tucker | Spalding | SR | Georgetown, Ky./Scott County | ||
| UT | Jaelin Holdaway | Webster | JR | West Valley, Utah/Cyprus | ||
| AL (OF) | Ashley Carrow | Fontbonne | FR | Jackson, Mo./Cape Notre Dame | ||
| SLIAC | Second Team | |||||
| P | Hailey Kutz | Fontbonne | SO | Cape Girardeau, Mo./Notre Dame | ||
| P | Reese Waggoner | Webster | JR | Centennial, Colo./Eaglecrest | ||
| C | Paige Thomas | Webster | JR | Emporia, Kan./Emporia | ||
| INF | Kaley Adzick | Webster | FR | Wildwood, Mo./Lafayette | ||
| INF | Madi Case | Greenville | SO | Apple Valley, Calif./Apple Valley | ||
| INF | Madison Loechle | Spalding | JR | Newcastle, Ky./Assumption | ||
| INF | Dawn Wilson | Spalding | SO | Eubank, Ky./Pulaski County | ||
| OF | Chelsea Ashlock | Blackburn | JR | Centralia, Ill./Centralia | ||
| OF | Emma Funk | Greenville | JR | Elkville, Ill./Elverado | ||
| OF | Maddie Marrero | Westminster | JR | Columbia, Mo./Rock Bridge | ||
| UT | Jaclyn Belzer | Greenville | SR | Belleville, Ill./Belleville East | ||
| AL (INF) | Kelsey Logan | Westminster | JR | Fulton, Mo./South Callaway | ||
| SLIAC | Third Team | |||||
| P | Ainsley Hinz | Webster | FR | Saskatoon, Saskatchewan/Centennial | ||
| P | Kami Matthews | Fontbonne | FR | Ballwin, Mo./Marquette | ||
| C | Hayleigh Gnagie | Spalding | SO | Louisville, Ky./Ballard | ||
| INF | Gada Bryant | Eureka | FR | Westville, Ill./Bizmark-Henning | ||
| INF | KayLee Hohlbauch | Eureka | SO | Arcola, Ill./Arcola | ||
| INF | Sidney Holtz | Webster | JR | Taylorsville, Utah/Murray | ||
| INF | Sarah Salas | Greenville | FR | Houston, Texas/Heights | ||
| INF | Bria Wessel | Eureka | JR | Peoria, Ill./Limestone | ||
| OF | Holly Heuerman | Blackburn | JR | Teutopolis, Ill./Teutopolis | ||
| OF | Kaelyn Kearney | Webster | JR | Draper, Utah/Corner Canyon | ||
| OF | Karlee Terral | Spalding | FR | Nicholasville, Ky./East Jessamine | ||
| OF | Macey Whisker | Eureka | JR | Washington, Ill./Washington | ||
| UT | Kaleigh Franklin-Brooks | Spalding | FR | Lexington, Ky./Lafayette | ||
| AL (P) | Melissa Bernal | Greenville | SO | Swansea, Ill./Gibault Catholic | ||
| SLIAC | All-Sportsmanship Team | |||||
| Michelle Hollon | Blackburn | |||||
| Kloey Wheeler | Eureka | |||||
| Patience VanderMierden | Fontbonne | |||||
| Desirae Yost | Greenville | |||||
| Kori Calvert | Spalding | |||||
| Ella Zgaynor | Webster | |||||
| Caroline Bentley | Westminster |